This award-winning waterfront Fort Myers Beach restaurant at Matanzas Inn offers stunning Estero Bay views. 

On the Bay, formerly known as Matanzas on the Bay, Friday, soft reopening for their iconic Fort Myers Beach restaurant is Friday, September 26, 2025. A grand reopening has been scheduled for Friday, Oct. 3, 2025.

On The Bay menu features a wide array of mouthwatering fresh seafood, steaks, burgers, salads, chowder, sandwiches, and more. 

Enjoy Happy Hour daily from 3 to 6 p.m. at the downstairs bar and Dave’s Dockside Pizza and live music nightly at Petey’s Upper Deck sports bar. 

Dine indoors or outside on the expansive deck. 

Arrive by car or boat! On The Bay at Matanzas Inn offers free parking and boat dockage!